Best Cyber Monday Fitness Equipment Deals See Deals
Best Cyber Monday Treadmill Deals See Deals
Best Cyber Monday Rowing Machine Deals See Deals
  • Best-in-Class Equipment
    • See All Roundups
    • Best Adjustable Dumbbells
    • Best Budget Home Gym Equipment
    • Best Cross-Training Shoes
    • Best Dumbbells
    • Best Exercise Bikes
    • Best Cold Plunge Tubs
    • Best Home Saunas
    • Best Ellipticals
    • Best Home Gym Machines
    • Best Kettlebells
    • Best Olympic Barbells
    • Best Rowing Machines
    • Best Squat Racks
    • Best Supplements
      • Best BCAA
      • Best Creatine
      • Best Greens Powder
      • Best Pre-Workout
      • Best Protein Powder
    • Best Treadmills
    • Best Weighted Vests
    • Best Weightlifting Shoes
    • Best Weight Benches
  • Reviews
    • See All Reviews
    • Barbells
    • Bodyweight
    • Certification Courses
    • Conditioning
    • Gym Accessories
    • Nutrition
    • Recovery
    • Rigs and Racks
    • Shoes
    • Strength Equipment
    • Support Gear
    • Technology
    • Training Programs
    • Weight Plates
  • Comparisons
    • See All Comparisons
    • Best Peloton Alternatives
    • Home Gym vs Gym Membership
    • Peloton Bike vs Bike Plus
    • PowerBlock vs Bowflex
    • Rogue Echo Bike vs Assault Air Bike
    • Rogue Ohio Power Bar vs Texas Power Bar
    • Tonal vs Tempo
  • Cyber Monday Deals
    • See All Cyber Monday Deals
    • Best Cyber Monday Supplement Sales (2025)
    • Peloton Cyber Monday Deals (2025)
    • Best Cyber Monday Sauna Deals (2025)
    • Best Cyber Monday Treadmill Deals (2025)
    • Best Cyber Monday Rowing Machine Deals (2025)
    • Best Cyber Monday Dumbbell Deals (2025)
    • Best Cyber Monday Elliptical Deals (2025)
    • Best Cyber Monday Exercise Bike Deals (2025)
    • The Best Massage Gun Cyber Monday Deals (2025)
    • Best Cyber Monday Deals for Runners (2025)
  • Coupons
    • Holiday Sales
    • Military Discounts
    • See All Coupons
      • Bells of Steel Coupons
      • REP Fitness Coupons
      • Rogue Fitness Coupons
      • Titan Fitness Coupons
      • Concept2 Coupons
      • Plunge Coupons
  • Equipment
    • Browse Gym Equipment
    • See All Equipment
    • Apparel
      • Shoes
        • Running Shoes
        • Training Shoes
        • Weightlifting Shoes
    • Strength Equipment
      • Barbells
      • Benches
      • Dumbbells
      • Glute Ham Developers (GHD)
      • Kettlebells
      • Rigs and Racks
      • Strength Machines
      • Weight Plates
    • Conditioning
      • Core and Stability
      • Endurance
        • Air Bikes
        • Ellipticals
        • Exercise Bikes
        • Rowing Machines
        • Treadmills
      • Jump Ropes
      • Strength Conditioning
    • Bodyweight
      • Climbing Ropes
      • Grip
      • Gymnastics
      • Pull-Up Systems
      • Training Equipment
    • Support Gear
      • Belts
      • Hand Protection
      • Mobility & Recovery
      • Straps & Wraps
      • Training Apparel
    • Gym Accessories
      • Flooring
      • Storage
    • Supplements
    • Technology
    • Training Programs
  • Home Gym Resources
    • See All Home Gym Resources
    • Calculators
    • DIY Guides
    • Equipment Guides
    • Gym Tours
    • Spotlight
    • Workout Guides
  • About Us
    • Meet Our Experts
    • GGR Fitness Equipment Testing Methodology
      • How We Test Ellipticals
      • How We Test Smart Home Gym Equipment
      • How We Test Smith Machines
      • How We Test Dumbbells and Adjustable Dumbbells
      • How We Test Barbells
      • How We Test Weight Benches
      • How We Test Treadmills
      • How We Test Saunas
      • How We Test Kettlebells and Adjustable Kettlebells 
      • How We Test Exercise Bikes
      • How We Test Cold Plunges
      • How We Test Massage Chairs 
      • How We Test Functional Trainers
    • GGR Supplement Testing Methodology
      • How We Test Pre-Workout Supplements
      • How We Test Creatine
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

Search

Sign Up

Log In

  • Best-in-Class Equipment
    • See All Roundups
    • Best Adjustable Dumbbells
    • Best Budget Home Gym Equipment
    • Best Cross-Training Shoes
    • Best Dumbbells
    • Best Exercise Bikes
    • Best Cold Plunge Tubs
    • Best Home Saunas
    • Best Ellipticals
    • Best Home Gym Machines
    • Best Kettlebells
    • Best Olympic Barbells
    • Best Rowing Machines
    • Best Squat Racks
    • Best Supplements
      • Best BCAA
      • Best Creatine
      • Best Greens Powder
      • Best Pre-Workout
      • Best Protein Powder
    • Best Treadmills
    • Best Weighted Vests
    • Best Weightlifting Shoes
    • Best Weight Benches
  • Reviews
    • See All Reviews
    • Barbells
    • Bodyweight
    • Certification Courses
    • Conditioning
    • Gym Accessories
    • Nutrition
    • Recovery
    • Rigs and Racks
    • Shoes
    • Strength Equipment
    • Support Gear
    • Technology
    • Training Programs
    • Weight Plates
  • Comparisons
    • See All Comparisons
    • Best Peloton Alternatives
    • Home Gym vs Gym Membership
    • Peloton Bike vs Bike Plus
    • PowerBlock vs Bowflex
    • Rogue Echo Bike vs Assault Air Bike
    • Rogue Ohio Power Bar vs Texas Power Bar
    • Tonal vs Tempo
  • Cyber Monday Deals
    • See All Cyber Monday Deals
    • Best Cyber Monday Supplement Sales (2025)
    • Peloton Cyber Monday Deals (2025)
    • Best Cyber Monday Sauna Deals (2025)
    • Best Cyber Monday Treadmill Deals (2025)
    • Best Cyber Monday Rowing Machine Deals (2025)
    • Best Cyber Monday Dumbbell Deals (2025)
    • Best Cyber Monday Elliptical Deals (2025)
    • Best Cyber Monday Exercise Bike Deals (2025)
    • The Best Massage Gun Cyber Monday Deals (2025)
    • Best Cyber Monday Deals for Runners (2025)
  • Coupons
    • Holiday Sales
    • Military Discounts
    • See All Coupons
      • Bells of Steel Coupons
      • REP Fitness Coupons
      • Rogue Fitness Coupons
      • Titan Fitness Coupons
      • Concept2 Coupons
      • Plunge Coupons
  • Equipment
    • Browse Gym Equipment
    • See All Equipment
    • Apparel
      • Shoes
        • Running Shoes
        • Training Shoes
        • Weightlifting Shoes
    • Strength Equipment
      • Barbells
      • Benches
      • Dumbbells
      • Glute Ham Developers (GHD)
      • Kettlebells
      • Rigs and Racks
      • Strength Machines
      • Weight Plates
    • Conditioning
      • Core and Stability
      • Endurance
        • Air Bikes
        • Ellipticals
        • Exercise Bikes
        • Rowing Machines
        • Treadmills
      • Jump Ropes
      • Strength Conditioning
    • Bodyweight
      • Climbing Ropes
      • Grip
      • Gymnastics
      • Pull-Up Systems
      • Training Equipment
    • Support Gear
      • Belts
      • Hand Protection
      • Mobility & Recovery
      • Straps & Wraps
      • Training Apparel
    • Gym Accessories
      • Flooring
      • Storage
    • Supplements
    • Technology
    • Training Programs
  • Home Gym Resources
    • See All Home Gym Resources
    • Calculators
    • DIY Guides
    • Equipment Guides
    • Gym Tours
    • Spotlight
    • Workout Guides
  • About Us
    • Meet Our Experts
    • GGR Fitness Equipment Testing Methodology
      • How We Test Ellipticals
      • How We Test Smart Home Gym Equipment
      • How We Test Smith Machines
      • How We Test Dumbbells and Adjustable Dumbbells
      • How We Test Barbells
      • How We Test Weight Benches
      • How We Test Treadmills
      • How We Test Saunas
      • How We Test Kettlebells and Adjustable Kettlebells 
      • How We Test Exercise Bikes
      • How We Test Cold Plunges
      • How We Test Massage Chairs 
      • How We Test Functional Trainers
    • GGR Supplement Testing Methodology
      • How We Test Pre-Workout Supplements
      • How We Test Creatine

Home » Resources » Guide » Home Gym vs. Gym Membership: Why Home Gyms are Better

Guides

Home Gym vs. Gym Membership: Why Home Gyms are Better

8023
Written by Amanda Capritto, CPT, CES, CNC, CF-L1, CSNC
8023
Amanda Capritto, CPT, CES, CNC, CF-L1, CSNC

Amanda is a content writer and journalist with extensive experience in the health, fitness, lifestyle, and nutrition niches. Before joining Garage Gym Reviews, she worked as an independent writer for various brands and outlets.

Her work has appeared in national and global digital publications, including Health.com and Shape.com (Meredith Corporation), CNET (Red Ventures, formerly ViacomCBS), LIVESTRONG (Leaf Group), Verywell Fit and The Balance (DotDash), SlickDeals (Goldman Sachs/Hearst), Health Journal, and more.

Now, Amanda brings her expertise in fitness to the GGR team by testing equipment and writing authentic, honest reviews on everything you might need to stock your home gym.

View Profile
Updated on September 6, 2023
Updated on September 6, 2023

We test and review fitness products based on an independent, multi-point methodology. If you use our links to purchase something, we may earn a commission. Read our disclosures

Coop holding a sign that says "Home gyms are better" in front of a Planet Fitness

15 Reasons to Convince You to Finally Ditch Your Gym Membership

There’s no doubt about it: Home gyms are here to stay. The face of fitness changed forever when the COVID-19 pandemic forced gyms and fitness studios to close. Even though gyms have, for the most part, reopened to pre-pandemic status, many people continue to work out at home—and the market for home exercise equipment shows it (impatiently waiting on several in-stock notifications for gear I’m vying for). 

In case you’re unsure what all the fuss is about, or if you’re teetering the line between building a home gym versus keeping your gym membership, here are 15 reasons why Coop, myself, and the rest of the Garage Gym Reviews team think home gyms are better.  

You Save Money On Membership Costs 

This is probably the number one reason for ditching your gym membership and making the switch to a home gym. While some gym memberships cost as little as $10 per month, others cost upwards of $200 per month. According to a RunRepeat study, the average cost of a gym membership per month is just over $30. That may not seem like a lot on the surface, but over the course of just one year, that’s $360—enough to buy a really nice Olympic barbell.  

Before you say, “But, the upfront costs,” just know Coop is somewhere rolling his eyes at you because, contrary to popular belief, it does not cost five figures to build a nice home workout space. In fact, you can build an entire gym setup on the cheap by using Amazon. There are plenty of ways to create a budget-friendly home gym. 

Plus, you don’t have to buy everything at once. If you do want to splurge on high-end equipment, you can always buy a few small things (like a pull-up bar or resistance bands), cut the gym membership, and use that money to save up for big-ticket items like a power rack or an elliptical. There are plenty of challenging bodyweight exercises to keep you in shape while you wait. 

You Save On Gas, Car Maintenance, Clothing, and More

In addition to saving the price of a monthly membership, having a home gym also provides other savings that may not seem like much on the surface, but add up over time. Gas is a good example. Even if your commercial gym is only a 10-minute drive from your home, going to the gym five days a week comes out to 100 minutes (nearly two hours) of driving. That’s quite a bit of gas, not to mention a lot of time driving.

And then, the more you drive your car, the more maintenance costs you’ll theoretically incur. You may buy food, supplements, and drinks from the gym snack bar just because it’s there. Maybe you spend more on new workout clothes because you want to look good at the gym. No judgement, but none of that matters if you have a home gym. You could work out in your rattiest T-shirt and a pair of boxers, and no one will care—because no one will be there to see.  

Coop using a Sharpie to write "Home gyms are better" on a piece of cardboard
About to rile up some gymgoers.

You Can Choose the Right Equipment for Your Goals 

Whether you’re into powerlifting, Olympic weightlifting, CrossFit, strongman events, bodybuilding, or something else entirely, having a home gym allows you to tailor equipment selection to your unique needs and goals. 

You can build a gym entirely with free weights, such as barbells, weight plates, dumbbells, and kettlebells, or fill it with space-saving workout equipment such as resistance bands, adjustable dumbbells, or adjustable kettlebells. 

You can even choose the smart home gym or functional trainer route—just one purchase can constitute an entire gym (a la Tonal).  

You End Up With Assets You Can Sell or Trade 

Having a gym membership is like renting a house instead of buying one. You’re dumping money monthly with nothing to show for it when all’s said and done. But when you buy equipment to build your own home gym, you can sell or trade items when you’re done with them. 

(We aren’t saying it’s never okay to go to a commercial gym or rent a house. Buying is certainly a smarter investment, but it’s not always the right time or situation.) 

Overlay of Coop in front of a home gym

You Lose the Commute 

Like I mentioned before, even a 10-minute drive quickly adds up to two hours or more per week if you work out five days a week. That’s a lot of time you could spend with your friends, family, on other obligations, or just relaxing. 

You Don’t Have to Wait Around for Equipment

Never stand awkwardly behind someone using the piece of equipment you need ever again. You never say the words, “Hey bro, what set are you on?” to the guy in the squat rack. And you’ll never have to pretend to stretch your calves while hawk-eyeing the cardio machines. 

You Don’t Have to Make Small Talk

You know that feeling of dread when you’re mid-workout and, out of the corner of the eye, you see the local gym socialite walking over? You just know you’re about to lose 20 minutes of your precious workout time. 

That won’t happen in your garage. Ditch the membership, ditch the small talk. Boom. Instant recipe for more gains. 

You Get More Time to Spend With Your Family

Thanks to your trusty home gym equipment, you’ll suddenly have a lot of extra time to dedicate to your family members. This is due in part to the lack of a commute, but also because of the above two points: You can simply walk to your gym, crush your workout, and be done. No waiting. No small talk. I’m a firm believer that I can get twice as much done in half the time when I work out at home compared to a commercial gym.  

You Won’t Feel Intimidated 

Big commercial gyms can feel intensely intimidating, especially for beginners. You won’t have to worry about feeling self-conscious in your own gym. Whether you’re trying to master deadlifts or get your first rep on the pull-up bar, there’s no need to worry about looking or feeling like you’re not good enough. It’s a no-judgement zone because no one’s there to judge. 

You Don’t Have to Follow Gym Etiquette

Grunt, scream, yell, and drop barbells all you want. Go on. You’re allowed—no one’s there to stop you. You can lasso as many items as you want and be a total equipment hog. You can switch from piece to piece and leave your sweat angels everywhere. 

You don’t even have to rerack the weights if you don’t want to. *Gasp*.  

You Can Work Out Whenever You Want

Sure, there are plenty of 24-hour gyms out there. But wouldn’t it be nice to just walk a few steps to get a late-night or early-morning workout in? I don’t know about you, but the thought of packing a gym bag, getting in my car, and driving 15 minutes at 5 a.m. dampens the workout experience for me. With a home gym, none of those barriers exist, instead, you can just simply go to your Carol Bike or squat rack and begin your workout.

RELATED: CAROL Bike Coupon

Full power rack in a home garage gym

You Get to Choose the Music (and Blare It) 

Home gym owners can listen to any music they like, as loud as they like, without headphones (assuming you don’t have sensitive neighbors or an intrusive HOA…). 

You Don’t Have to Share a Bathroom

Bid sayonara to shared bathrooms and deal with urgent workout-induced bowel movements (we’ve all been there) in the peace of your own cozy bathroom. You’ll also never have to get dressed for work in a locker room ever again. 

You Don’t Have to Worry About Cleanliness 

There’s no risk of contracting infectious diseases in your own gym. You won’t have to worry about catching COVID-19, the flu, or a regular ol’ cold. You don’t have to sanitize equipment before and after each use; you can work out barefoot without getting athlete’s foot; and you can lie down on an exercise mat without wondering what kind of germs are living there. 

There’s No Risk of Harassment 

A very real reason to drop your gym membership is to avoid the risk of harassment in the gym. According to a RunRepeat study, nearly 60% of women report harassment in the gym, and nearly 20% of those women cite it as a reason to quit going to the gym altogether. The study also reports that 21% of men experience harassment in commercial gyms. In your own home gym, safety and comfort aren’t compromised.  

A meme showing Coop's sitting behind a table with a poster saying "Home Gyms are the Future of Fitness. Change My Mind."

Home Gym vs. Gym Membership: When Is a Gym Membership the Right Choice? 

As much as the Garage Gym Reviews team loves home gyms, we recognize that sometimes going to a local gym is the right choice. 

Membership fees may not be a bad investment for someone who actually gets the most out of it and has no feasible way to recreate some of the features and offerings at home. For example, maintaining a membership might be worth it for someone who regularly uses the gym sauna or swimming pool along with the strength training and cardio equipment at their gym. 

Also, going to a gym is a great way to make new friends if you recently moved to a new city or just want to find a new crowd. I’m not embarrassed to admit that the only reason I have friends where I live now is because I went to a CrossFit gym for a year before building the home gym setup in my backyard. (If you are worried about losing the social aspect of fitness by working out at home, you may consider investing in a home gym system that has a strong community aspect, such as the Lululemon MIRROR.)

People who compete or regularly need a spotter may also benefit from a gym membership, depending on the type of gym. 

Finally, gym membership costs might be worthwhile if you move around a lot. Building a home gym is a big undertaking, and it might not make sense to do so if you know you’re moving in a year or two. 

Ultimately, the home gym versus gym membership debate comes down to personal circumstance and preference. For most people, however, we believe a home gym is the right long-term choice.

Further Reading

How to Cold Plunge: Expert Insights on How to Get the Most Out of Your Ice Bath

How to Cold Plunge: Expert Insights on How to Get the Most Out of Your Ice Bath

Cold water immersion has never been hotter! Our guide shares how to cold plunge, plus the many benefits of cold plunging. Check it out!
Read More
5 Interval Training Workouts Designed By A Certified Personal Trainer

5 Interval Training Workouts Designed By A Certified Personal Trainer

Our 5 interval training workouts designed by a certified personal trainer (CPT) can help improve your cardio fitness and support weight loss. Learn more now!
Read More
MuscleTech Creatine Review (2025): Support Your Muscle-Building with This Classic Brand

MuscleTech Creatine Review (2025): Support Your Muscle-Building with This Classic Brand

MuscleTech Creatine Review
Read More
4 HIIT Bike Workouts to Try at Home Guaranteed to Break a Sweat

4 HIIT Bike Workouts to Try at Home Guaranteed to Break a Sweat

Looking for a HIIT bike workout to help you break a sweat? Team GGR has you covered with four ideas.
Read More

On This Page

You Save Money On Membership Costs 
You Save On Gas, Car Maintenance, Clothing, and More
You Can Choose the Right Equipment for Your Goals 
You End Up With Assets You Can Sell or Trade 
You Lose the Commute 
You Don’t Have to Wait Around for Equipment
You Don’t Have to Make Small Talk
You Get More Time to Spend With Your Family
You Won’t Feel Intimidated 
You Don’t Have to Follow Gym Etiquette
You Can Work Out Whenever You Want
You Get to Choose the Music (and Blare It) 
You Don’t Have to Share a Bathroom
You Don’t Have to Worry About Cleanliness 
There’s No Risk of Harassment 
Home Gym vs. Gym Membership: When Is a Gym Membership the Right Choice? 

Connect With Your Community

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • https://www.google.com

Get the Latest Reviews & Updates

  • About
  • Careers
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Expert Panel
  • Affiliate Disclosure
  • Contact
  • Do Not Sell My Info
Reviews
  • Nike Grind Bumper Plates Review (2025): Are These Plates Worthy of a Spot in Your Garage Gym?

  • MERACH T12 Foldable Walking Treadmill Review (2025): A Compact and Affordable Option

  • Evolve Plant-Based Protein Shake Review (2025): Is This Low-Calorie Pea Protein Worth the Price?

  • Huel Ready-to-Drink Review (2025): Can This RTD Really Replace A Meal?

  • C4 Ultimate Shred Review (2025): Is This Fat-Burning Pre-Workout Worth It?

Equipment
  • The Best Exercise Bikes of 2025: Cycle Smarter With Our Expert-Approved Picks

  • The 13 Best Treadmills for Your Home Gym in 2025, According to Personal Trainers

  • The 12 Best Rowing Machines For Your Home Gym: Expert-Tested and Favorited (2025)

  • The Best Adjustable Kettlebells to Take for a Swing in Your Home Gym (2025)

  • Best Recumbent Exercise Bikes (2025): Top Picks from Certified Personal Trainers

Guides
  • Guide to Protein Powder: Scoop the 411 From an RD

  • Infrared Saunas Buyer’s Guide: Everything You Need to Know to Break a Sweat With Confidence

  • The Ultimate Sauna Guide: Expert Tips on Benefits, How to Use, and More

  • What Foods Have Probiotics? Colon-Ize Your Plate with Help From a Dietitian

  • Home Gym Con 2025 Recap: The New Equipment We’re Most Excited About

DIY
  • Your Expert Guide to Making Budget-Friendly DIY Ankle Weights  

  • Homemade Protein Powder: The Right Whey to Do Home-Cooked Protein

  • Building a DIY Rowing Machine: How to, Why, and Should You?

  • Try These DIY Cold Plunge Ideas To Jump-Start Your Recovery 

  • DIY Mass Gainer: You Make the Shake, and Your Body Makes the Muscle

The Most Trusted Voice in Fitness

© Garage Gym Reviews 2023 | All Rights Reserved.

GGR

  • About
  • Careers
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Expert Panel
  • Affiliate Disclosure
  • Contact
  • Do Not Sell My Info

The Most Trusted Voice in Fitness

© Garage Gym Reviews 2025 | All Rights Reserved.

Reviews
  • Nike Grind Bumper Plates Review (2025): Are These Plates Worthy of a Spot in Your Garage Gym?
  • MERACH T12 Foldable Walking Treadmill Review (2025): A Compact and Affordable Option
  • Evolve Plant-Based Protein Shake Review (2025): Is This Low-Calorie Pea Protein Worth the Price?
  • Huel Ready-to-Drink Review (2025): Can This RTD Really Replace A Meal?
  • C4 Ultimate Shred Review (2025): Is This Fat-Burning Pre-Workout Worth It?
Equipment
  • The Best Exercise Bikes of 2025: Cycle Smarter With Our Expert-Approved Picks
  • The 13 Best Treadmills for Your Home Gym in 2025, According to Personal Trainers
  • The 12 Best Rowing Machines For Your Home Gym: Expert-Tested and Favorited (2025)
  • The Best Adjustable Kettlebells to Take for a Swing in Your Home Gym (2025)
  • Best Recumbent Exercise Bikes (2025): Top Picks from Certified Personal Trainers
Guides
  • Guide to Protein Powder: Scoop the 411 From an RD
  • Infrared Saunas Buyer’s Guide: Everything You Need to Know to Break a Sweat With Confidence
  • The Ultimate Sauna Guide: Expert Tips on Benefits, How to Use, and More
  • What Foods Have Probiotics? Colon-Ize Your Plate with Help From a Dietitian
  • Home Gym Con 2025 Recap: The New Equipment We’re Most Excited About
DIY
  • Your Expert Guide to Making Budget-Friendly DIY Ankle Weights  
  • Homemade Protein Powder: The Right Whey to Do Home-Cooked Protein
  • Building a DIY Rowing Machine: How to, Why, and Should You?
  • Try These DIY Cold Plunge Ideas To Jump-Start Your Recovery 
  • DIY Mass Gainer: You Make the Shake, and Your Body Makes the Muscle