Home / Reviews / American Barbell Urethane Bumper Plates Review

American Barbell Urethane Bumper Plates Review

American Barbell is by and large making some of the best training equipment available, and the Urethane Pro Series Bumper Plates are no exception. Utilizing urethane instead of the traditional rubber creates an ultra-durable, low bounce plate, with vibrant colors. These are the best competition bumper plates we've had the opportunity to review to date.

Table of Contents

Urethane vs. Rubber Bumper Plates

When it comes to bumper plates, you pretty much have one material choice and that is rubber.

Rubber is and has been used as the main component in bumper plates since their introduction in the 1960's. At the time, Olympic Weightlifters were still using steel loading plates, but in an effort to improve what was used, European companies began developing tire like solid rubber plates with internal steel cores.

The bumper plate undoubtedly has its place in nearly every gym in the world for good reason. Bumper plates prevent damage to the bar, flooring, and take wear much better than cast-iron steel plates. Up until a few years ago, rubber was about the only material used in bumper plates. Today, more and more companies are selling bumper plates using urethane and there are many reasons why.

Before I give my opinion on urethane's use in bumper plates, it must first be said that urethane hasn't always been a viable option. In 1985, a company by the name of Superior Barbell came out with urethane plates that had great promise, but ultimately cracked easily. Later, other companies tried to improve the process, but ultimately came up short time and time again. Although I don't have an exact answer on who produced the first durable urethane bumper plate, I do know that the ones sold today are vastly better than the ones first introduced.

Urethane is an improvement upon rubber for a few reasons. First, if the correct formula is used, they can be incredibly durable. In fact, the American Barbell Urethane Plates are tested to 50,000 drops and still show little wear. There simply isn't a more durable plate available.

Second, urethane plates have a much more dead bounce, which keeps the bar from flying all over the gym. This is an obvious benefit for anyone who's used hi-temps that rebound like bouncy balls.

Finally, urethane allows manufacturers to use vibrant colors that rubber doesn't. Without a doubt, the colors used on urethane plates are some of the most attractive I've seen.

With all this said, Urethane does have shortcomings, but I'll speak more on those in the actual review.

Video

Unboxing

The American Barbell Urethane Bumper Plates showed up on my doorstep rather quickly. I'd been anticipating receiving these plates for sometime as I'd been doing research for a bumper plate guide and stumbled upon urethane and its many uses.

Pictures seriously do not do these justice. Not only are they incredibly durable, which I'll get into more on that later, their colors are the most vibrant I've seen. Nothing I've used compares to the look of these plates.

American Barbell Urethane Bumper Plates Review

American Barbell is producing some outstanding equipment. We've reviewed a couple of their barbells in the past, and although they don't get as much recognition as some other offerings on the market, they're every bit as good.

In addition to barbells, American Barbell has just about every piece of equipment you'd want, including Bumper Plates.

I've had the opportunity to use many different bumper plates, but this is the first set of urethane plates I've ever come across. As illustrated above, urethane is much different from the rubber that is traditionally used by nearly every other bumper plate available.

But, before I get into the performance of the units, let me first discuss the superficial details.

First off, these are the brightest bumper plates I've ever seen. In pictures, it's obvious that the color is more vibrant, but they're nothing like what you see in person. The first time I opened the box of the 25 kg plates I was blown away.

For most people, the brighter colors are a cool feature. They're something that stands out in the gym, while still being within the standard colors for each stated weight. However, if you're someone who wants every plate in your gym to match, and you already have quite a few bumper plates, understand that these won't easily blend in. But, for me, I like things that stand out.

All of the colors, despite being bright, resist scuffing pretty well… except for the 15 kg yellow plates. For some reason, I'm guessing due to their shade, the yellow get's scuffed very easily, however, due to the hardness of the rubber, they clean up very easily.

As you get closer to the plate, you notice they have a pebble finish. One of the big knocks on urethane plates in the past was how slippery they were. Due to a low coefficient of friction, urethane plates were known to slip out of people's hands, breaking toes, feet, and all sorts of other things. Although the American Barbell Urethane Plates aren't the easiest plates to grip, the pebbled coating is a welcomed feature. There's no doubt that these urethane plates are harder to pick up and hold than standard rubber plates, but it isn't a big enough issue to avoid them because of that.

Knowing that urethane is notoriously slippery and at heavier weights may be difficult for people to hold, American Barbell also added a lip to the outside of the plate. Although the lip is definitely needed and helpful when transferring plates from the ground or rack to the bar, it does make it somewhat difficult to pick the plates off the ground when lying flat. This again isn't a big problem, but something to be aware of.

One reason for the difficulty in removing the plates from the ground when lying flat is due to the plates squared off profile. The squared edge helps to keep the plates from flying all over the gym after being dropped and likely has something to do with the way plates have to be manufactured to prevent the urethane from cracking. The square profile has a great look, and is another feature that helps to make the plates stand-out.

The identifying numbers on the face of the plates have a contrasting color that stands out, but not overly so, while the American Barbell logo is the same color as the plate.

Overall, the American Barbell Urethane Plates are some of the best looking plates on the market. There are a few others that give them a run for their money, such as the unique Klokov Plates, but not many.

When it comes to performance, there isn't a more durable bumper plate available than these. Most bumper plates are tested to 5,000 drops, including the most well-respected bumper plates in the world, Eleiko's. American Barbell tests these Urethane plates to 55,000 drops from 8.5 ft and the only change to the plate that was done was some dirt that had to be wiped off after.

American Barbell's urethane actually comes from Germany and in talking with a representative is said to be the most durable material that is currently being used in bumper plates.

It must be said that a few other companies are selling urethane bumper plates, but American Barbell is the company who holds the patent in China, so, I would assume that many of the bumper plates you see on the market currently are simply rebranded versions of American Barbell's.

Urethane also has a much lower bounce than the rubber used in traditional bumper plates. Rather than bouncing high and flying all over the platform, these plates bounce slightly low and stay low. The only downside of this is that they do make a bit more noise when dropped than traditional bumper plates.

Regarding the accuracy of the plates, they were very close to the stated weight. Using a calibrated postage scale that was tested first on a weight I know is exact, all of the plates were within the stated allotment of weight.

Although plates that are a couple of pounds off isn't a huge deal, when you're spending money on plates that cost this much, they should be pretty close to the stated weight. Thankfully these are.

They're also slightly thinner than most competition training plates. I measured them compared to other plates we have on hand including Pendlay Elites and Rogue Competiton Bumpers and I was pleasantly suprised to see the comparison. A thinner plate simply means you can fit more of them on the bar, which matters for those that use bumper plates for deadlifts and squats.

One unique feature on these plates is the fact that the center hub is one piece. This prevents it from separating from the urethane and provides a clean and uniform look.

After using the American Barbell Urethane Bumper Plates in various workouts, including the clean and jerk and the snatch, I can confidently recommend them to anyone looking for a competition bumper plate that is made to stand the test of time and look good while doing it.

Suggested Improvements

One of our goals at Garage Gym Reviews is to be unbiased and honest in our reviews. For this reason, we like to provide ways that a product can be improved. Although the American Barbell Urethane Bumper Plates are fantastic, there is one improvement we'd like to see.

As discussed in the review, one minor dislike we had with the plates was the difficulty in picking them off the ground. Due the plates having such an extremely squared-off profile, getting a finger under the plates to get a grip is very difficult. In order to make it easier for them to be lifted off the ground, we suggest making the corner slightly more round.

Although this is a minor change, we believe it would make the plates easier to move from the ground to the bar.

Competition Bumper Plate Comparison Table

Bumper PlatesPriceCountry of OriginDurometer RatingMaterial UsedWarranty
Rogue Competition Bumper Plates$1,035Imported (Likely China)94RubberNot Listed
Rogue Urethane Bumper Plates$1,100Imported (Likely China)90UrethaneNot Listed
American Barbell Urethane Bumper Plates$1,386China90Urethane3-Year
Vulcan Competition Bumper Plates$1,152Imported (Likely China)85-87RubberNot Listed
FringeSport Competition Bumper Plates$784Imported (Likely China)90Rubber1-Year
Rep Fitness Competition Bumper Plates$750Imported (Likely China)92Rubber5-Year
Titan Fitness Competition Bumper Plates$865Imported (Likely China)90RubberNot Listed
Get RXd Competition Bumper Plates$960Imported (Likely China)90Rubber3-Year
Klokov Competition Bumper Plates$834Imported (Likely China)Not ListedRubber5-Year
Uesaka Competition Bumper Plates$2,564Not ListedNot ListedRubber5-Year
Eleiko Competition Bumper Plates$2,291Swedish Materials?Not ListedRubber5-Year

Full Rating

American Barbell is by and large making some of the best training equipment available, and the Urethane Pro Series Bumper Plates are no exception. Utilizing urethane instead of the traditional rubber creates an ultra-durable, low bounce plate, with vibrant colors. These are the best competition bumper plates we've had the opportunity to review to date. Table of Contents Urethane vs. Rubber Bumper Plates Unboxing Video American Barbell Urethane Bumper Plates Review Suggested improvements Competition Bumper Plate Comparison Table Full rating Where to purchase Urethane vs. Rubber Bumper Plates When it comes to bumper plates, you pretty much have one material choice…

American Barbell Urethane Bumper Plates Review

Overall Construction
Appearance
Noise
Bounce
Value
Materials Used

Excellent

American Barbell is by and large making some of the best training equipment available, and the Urethane Pro Series Bumper Plates are no exception. Utilizing urethane instead of the traditional rubber creates an ultra-durable, low bounce plate, with vibrant colors. These are the best competition bumper plates we've had the opportunity to review to date.

American Barbell ($248+)
User Rating: 5 ( 1 votes)

Where to Purchase

About Coop

Hello fellow fitness fanatics and equipment fueled fiends. I'm Coop and when not training I can be found mostly operating other entrepreneurial ventures including my gym Intentional Fitness & Performance, spending time with my Wife and family, and worshipping my risen Savior. You can find more about me here.

Check Also

Bells of Steel Trap Bar 2.0 Review: Unique Features, Great Value

The Bells of Steel Trap Bar 2.0 is one of many trap bars on the …

Top